Tax Litigation
Request a Consultation
When administrative remedies fall short or the IRS simply won’t budge, you can escalate your argument to the courts. While judicial court cases are relatively rare—fewer than 21,000 cases were filed in US Tax Court in fiscal year 2023 compared to over 163 million individual returns processed—understanding your litigation options is essential when the stakes are high.
The Three Trial Courts for Tax Cases
US Tax Court specializes in tax matters with judges who understand the complexities of tax law. The Tax Court offers a unique advantage: you can contest the IRS’s determination without first paying the disputed tax. Proceedings are less formal than other federal courts, and many cases qualify for ‘small tax case’ procedures with simplified rules if $50,000 or less is at issue.
US District Court may be your best option if you prefer a jury trial. However, you must first pay the disputed tax and then file a refund claim. District Court judges handle a wide variety of cases, so when your argument appeals to broader legal principles rather than technical tax regulations, you might get better results here.
US Court of Federal Claims also requires full payment before filing suit for a refund. This court offers nationwide jurisdiction but no jury trials. If the Federal Circuit Court has ruled in favor of cases similar to yours, this venue may work well.
The Notice of Deficiency: Your Ticket to Tax Court
The judicial route is triggered when the IRS issues a ninety-day letter, formally called a Statutory Notice of Deficiency. From the date the notice is issued, you have exactly ninety days to file a petition with the Tax Court challenging the IRS’s proposed changes. This deadline is absolute—missing it eliminates your Tax Court rights for that tax year.
Can You Represent Yourself in Tax Court?
Tax Court rules allow taxpayers to represent themselves, and many do in small tax cases. However, representing yourself carries significant risks. Tax litigation involves complex procedural rules, evidence rules, and legal arguments. Judges are often sympathetic to unrepresented taxpayers but cannot advocate for your position. Critical deadlines can result in losing your case entirely if missed.